Past and current BlueFins that have continued their swimming careers in college:
| High School Graduation | Swimmer | School | |
| 2023 | Mary Evans | Allegheny College | |
| Claire Gorton | Niagara University | ||
| Lauren Martin | Canisius University | ||
| Alexa von Holtz | Ball State University | ||
| Mingna Xu | Cornell University | ||
| 2022 | Spencer Anderson | Rochester Institute of Technology | |
| Anna Baker | SUNY Oswego | ||
| Jon Farnham | SUNY New Paltz | ||
| Abby Funk | SUNY Geneseo | ||
| Hannah Gentile | University of Rochester | ||
| Emily Lefrois-Heath | SUNY Brockport | ||
| Katy Shaw 2023, 2024 NCAA All-American |
Harvey Mudd College | ||
| 2021 | Mike Damelio | Tufts University | |
| Jordan Fixsen | Alfred University | ||
| Ellen Patterson | Clarkson University | ||
| Carson Rehkopf | Colby College | ||
| Lauren Schreiner | Binghamton University | ||
| Tyler Searles | Emmanuel College | ||
| Suzanne Sokolowski 2022 NCAA All-American |
University of Chicago | ||
| Paul Tuttle | Alfred University | ||
| Dana Witte | Colgate University | ||
| Alicia Wood | SUNY Buffalo | ||
| 2020 | Lauren Audi | Rochester Institute of Technology | |
| Matt Delgrego | Roger Williams University | ||
| Zoë Masters | Rochester Institute of Technology | ||
| Maria Naccarella | SUNY Buffalo | ||
| 2019 | Sarah Gartner | Franklin & Marshall College | |
| Daniel Russotti | SUNY Potsdam | ||
| Griffin Witte | St. Bonaventure University | ||
| Payton Wolcott | Clarkson University | ||
| 2018 | Anna Eggert | Nazareth College | |
| Toni Naccarella 2021, 2023 NCAA Qualifier |
SUNY Buffalo | ||
| Oliver Smith | United States Naval Acadamy | ||
| 2017 | Alec Wahl 2019, 2020, 2022 NCAA All-American |
Franklin & Marshall College | |
| 2016 | Eric Eggert | SUNY Brockport | |
| Pat Marsh | Monroe Community College | ||
| Lauren Nicastro | Niagara University | ||
| Mike Sanchez | Union College | ||
| 2015 | Sydney Krisanda | Connecticut College | |
| Kelly Martin | Worchester Polytechnic Institute | ||
| Emily Nicastro | Lemoyne College | ||
| Kristina Posnick | University of Vermont | ||
| Ilya Shinkeyev | Monroe Community College | ||
| Paul Steve | University of Rochester | ||
| 2014 | Amanda Carroll | Allegheny College | |
| 2013 | Emily Martin | Worchester Polytechnic Institute | |
| Claire Piampiano | SUNY Oneonta | ||
| Joe Mulvehill | Hartwick College | ||
| Shannon O'Malley | Nazareth College | ||
| 2012 | Emma Pullano | Niagara University | |
| 2011 | Meg Buisman | Ithaca College | |
| Kelly Mulvehill | Clarkson University | ||
| Sara Nungesser | Canisius College | ||
| 2010 | John Crawford | SUNY Maritime | |
| Kristina Pelletier | Monroe Community College | ||
| 2009 | Nick Dubois | SUNY New Paltz | |
| Paul Garman | SUNY Buffalo | ||
| Lauren Karl | Allegheny College | ||
| Chelsea Krisanda | University of Vermont | ||
| Katie Lohrman | SUNY Geneseo | ||
| Matt Wahl | Union College | ||
| Zack Wahl 2013 NCAA All-American |
Union College | ||
| 2008 | Kevin Christiansen | Rochester Institute of Technology | |
| Megan Foster | Edinboro University | ||
| Ethan Mahoney | Niagara University | ||
| Christine Reith | SUNY New Paltz | ||
| 2006 | Kaitlin Rosinski | Ithaca College | |
| 2005 | Colleen Emaus | University of Michigan | |
| 2003 | Chris Ekimoff | St. Bonaventure University | |
| Megan Rosinski | Nazareth College | ||
| 2002 | Andrew Lloyd | SUNY Oswego | |
| Mike Phelps | Ithaca College | ||
